All-Americans (33)

Please note: The list of recipients of All-American status are those honored on the First Team, Second Team or Honorable Mention Team by the governing body United States Collegiate Athletic Association (USCAA). Specific to the sport of wrestling, All-American recognition is from the National Collegiate Wrestling Association (NCWA).

Baseball (10)
Matt Clark - 2015
Alex Cline - 2015, 2016
Derek Coy - 2011, 2015
Clayton Eberhardt - 2015
Brady Griest - 2016
Matt Taylor - 2016
Brady Topper - 2017
Nathan Topper - 2012
Justin Warner - 2013
Jeremiah Younker - 2016, 2017

Men's Basketball (3)
Jerome Evans - 2014, 2016, 2017
Devonte Merrit – 2015
Sharif Welton- 2015

Golf (6)
Austin Green - 2015, 2016
Chase King - 2012
Scott Levy - 2010
Adam Poulson - 2012
Kevin Reiber - 2010
Dan Zeiders - 2010

Women's Soccer (2)
Kennedy Guerin – 2016
Taylor Zeiders - 2016

Softball (5)
Sarah Bortner - 2014
Kristyan Gates - 2011
Jessica Miller - 2012
Brooke Porter – 2014, 2016
MacKenzie Trafka – 2013

Women's Volleyball (4)
Alex Henault - 2008
Jenn Stremmel - 2009
Kelsey Wetzel - 2015
Alyssa Booth - 2016

Wrestling (3)
Clay Kocsis – 2015, 2016, 2017
James Hughes - 2014
Tyler Warner - 2016